OUTRANKED.ME

How to promote a local business online

By Outranked.me · published · updated · 7 min read

A business serving one town competes on a different board from the rest of the web, and most national marketing advice is actively unhelpful for it.

A business serving one town is competing on a different board from the rest of the web, and most marketing advice does not know that.

The national advice assumes you want to be found by anyone, anywhere, and that your competition is everyone selling the same thing. Neither is true for a hair salon in Leicester. You want to be found by people within a few miles who need what you do this week, and your competition is the eleven other salons those people can also reach. That is a much smaller, much more winnable problem — and it is solved with different tools.

This is the local hub for the wider guide to promoting a business online. Everything here assumes you serve a place.

The single most important thing to understand

There are two separate sets of results, and they have different rules.

When someone searches "plumber near me", Google typically shows a map with a handful of businesses on it, and beneath that the ordinary blue-link results. These are produced by different systems.

| | The map results | The ordinary results | |---|---|---| | What it shows | Businesses, with distance, hours, reviews | Web pages | | Main asset | Your Google Business Profile | Your website | | Distance matters | Enormously | Barely | | Reviews matter | Directly and visibly | Not directly | | Cost to enter | Free | A website, plus time |

For most local businesses, the map results are worth more than the ordinary results, because that is where people with immediate intent look first, and because you can compete there without a good website.

That is the opposite of the advice most local businesses receive, which starts and ends with "you need a better website". How the local pack differs from organic results goes into the mechanics.

Start here: your Google Business Profile

Free, takes an afternoon, and produces phone calls faster than anything else on this list.

Claim it, verify it, and then fill in the parts everyone skips:

  • Primary category. The single highest-impact field. "Plumber" and "Heating contractor" surface for different searches. Choose the one that matches what you most want to be called for, and add secondary categories for the rest.
  • Services or products, listed individually. Each one is a thing you can be matched against.
  • Service areas, if you travel to customers rather than the reverse.
  • Hours, including the special hours for bank holidays that everyone forgets and customers notice.
  • Photos, added regularly rather than once. Interiors, exteriors, work in progress, the team.
  • Questions and answers. You are allowed to ask and answer your own. The questions customers actually ring up about belong here.

Then keep it alive. A profile updated monthly behaves differently from one filled in three years ago and abandoned.

Reviews, honestly

Reviews affect what customers choose and they are visible in the results, which makes them one of the few things that improves both your ranking position and your conversion at the same time.

The rules that matter:

  • Ask everyone, routinely. The single biggest cause of few reviews is not asking. Build it into the job — after the work is signed off, not three weeks later.
  • Do not incentivise them. Offering a discount for a review breaches most platforms' policies and produces reviews that read as bought, which customers detect.
  • Do not gate them. Asking only happy customers, or screening people before directing them to the review form, is against the guidelines.
  • Reply to all of them, including the bad ones. The reply is not for the reviewer. It is for the next person reading, who wants to know how you handle a problem.

A steady trickle of ordinary four- and five-star reviews with sensible replies beats a burst of ten perfect ones in a week, which looks exactly like what it is.

Proximity: the constraint nobody tells you about

You cannot rank everywhere, and no amount of work will change that.

Distance from the searcher is a major input to the map results. A business in the north of a city will struggle to appear for searches made in the south, even against weaker competitors, because the person searching is closer to them. This is the correct behaviour — the searcher wants someone nearby — but it surprises people who assume effort alone decides position.

What this means practically:

  • Checking your own ranking from your own premises tells you almost nothing. You are standing at the point where you rank best.
  • If you want coverage across a city, you need either multiple genuine locations or acceptance that you will be strong in one part of it.
  • A business that travels to customers should set service areas honestly rather than claiming the whole county, which does not help.

Where the website actually fits

Smaller than most people are told, but not nothing.

The website's jobs for a local business, in order:

  1. Confirm you are real and competent to someone who found you in the map results and is deciding whether to ring. This is the main job. Most local websites fail it by being vague about what they do and where.
  2. Rank for the searches the map does not cover — longer, more specific queries where someone is researching rather than choosing.
  3. Convert. Phone number visible without scrolling, on every page, tappable on a phone.

A five-page site that is specific about services, area and price range outperforms a twenty-page site of generic copy. If you serve several towns, resist the temptation to spin up a page per town with the name swapped — that pattern is a thin doorway page, and there is a right way to do it covered in local landing pages that are not thin doorway pages.

Consistency of your details

Your business name, address and phone number appear in dozens of places: your site, your profile, directories, your social accounts, old listings you have forgotten about.

When these disagree — an old phone number, a former address, "Ltd" in some places and not others — it makes you harder to identify as one business. Fixing it is dull, one-off work with a real payoff. Search your business name and phone number and correct what you find.

Local link building is genuinely easier than national link building, because the sources are physically nearby and have no reason to ignore you.

Sponsorship of a local team or event, membership of the chamber of commerce or a trade association, supplier and partner pages, the local paper's business section, community noticeboards, and being useful in local Facebook groups. None of this is glamorous and all of it works. The general method is in how to get your first backlinks when nobody has heard of you.

An order of work

| Week | Do this | Why now | |---|---|---| | 1 | Claim and fully complete the Business Profile | Free, fastest return | | 1 | Fix name, address and phone consistency everywhere | One-off, blocks nothing else | | 2 | Start asking every customer for a review, every time | Compounds slowly, so start early | | 2–3 | Make the website specific about services and area | Converts the traffic the profile brings | | 4+ | One local link per month: sponsorship, association, supplier | Slow, permanent | | Ongoing | Photos, posts, answering questions monthly | Keeps the profile active |

The mistakes that cost most

Treating the website as the priority. For most local businesses it is the second asset, not the first.

Creating a page for every town within fifty miles. Thin, near-identical location pages are a well-known pattern and they do not work.

Chasing reviews in bursts. Ten reviews in one week after two years of silence is a pattern, and not a flattering one.

Judging your rankings from your own shop. Ask a customer across town what they see.

Ignoring the profile once it is set up. It is the asset that most rewards small, regular attention.

Where paid placement fits, and where it does not

We run a marketplace where businesses pay for visibility, so treat this section sceptically.

For a genuinely local business, the free work above usually beats paying for placement, and it is not close. A complete Business Profile with steady reviews will out-earn most paid options for a plumber or a salon, because local intent is so concentrated in the map results that you can win them without spending.

Paid placement makes more sense when you serve a wider area than your proximity allows you to rank in, when you are new and have no reviews yet, or when you sell something people research rather than search for urgently. If that is you, what visibility costs and the current rankings board show the actual prices before you commit to anything.

Common questions

How long before the Business Profile produces calls? Often within weeks, which is unusually fast for anything in search.

Do I need a website at all? You can get calls without one. You will convert more of them with one.

Should I pay for a citation-building service? Usually not. A handful of relevant directories matter; the hundreds that these services submit to do not.

My competitor has worse reviews and ranks above me. Check distance first. It is nearly always distance.

Sources

See the data behind this

Outranked.me ranks businesses by verified spend, and publishes the whole record: the live leaderboard, every position change with the competitor that caused it, and the open dataset behind both.

Read next